Alternatives
Scrappy DIY Solutions
So the elephant in the room is, do you really need to pay $140 for the Axle Pack + Fit Kit when bikepackers have been attaching cargo cages to their forks with hose clamps and electrical tape since the dawn of time?
Technically the Axle Pack does not solve a problem that cannot be solved in other ways. But it does solve that problem more reliably, safely, and conveniently in many cases.
Hose clamps are the classic way to mount cages to forks without built-in mounts, and they’re dirt cheap. Sturdy zip ties are a similar idea. Be sure to put a few layers of electrical tape, cloth rim tape, or thin innertube underneath for padding!
Purpose-built mounts like the Topeak Versa Mount, and a variety of questionable cheap gadgets on Amazon, imitate hose clamps with a bit more polish. I used one by Zefal years ago to mount bottle cages to my Long Haul Trucker. It was workable but not elegant, and eventually broke.
Related: Creative Ideas for Bikepacking on a Budget
Hose clamps and related solutions can work well in limited cases: mounting certain types of cages with light loads to perfectly round fork blades with uniform diameter. I would feel comfortable using them to mount a standard bottle cage to my suspension fork, for example, but not to mount a heavy cargo cage to a carbon fork that isn’t round and narrows toward the bottom.
Caution: Be very careful using clamps on carbon forks (risk of damaging the fork) and especially tapered fork blades that get narrower toward the bottom. If your cage were to slip downward and loosen, it could rotate into the front wheel causing a nasty crash. Though I’m sure people have gotten away with it, the official advice is not to try it.
Electrical tape is other option for carbon forks and non-round shapes. Carefully pad the fork blade under the cage, then wrap an obscene amount of electrical tape around the entire length of the cage. This is obviously a pain to mount and remove, so don’t plan on swapping your cages between bikes. It’s also not safe for blades that taper toward the bottom due to risk of slipping, no matter how sticky that tape seems.
Compared to these cheap and cheerful alternatives, the Axle Pack has some significant advantages:
- No risk of spinning into wheel and causing a crash
- No slipping or fiddling
- Can reliably support a heavier load
- Easier to install and remove
- Works with carbon forks or other shapes that aren’t round
- Works with certain cargo cages, like the Salsa Anything EXP, that aren’t shaped well for DIY mount solutions
- No risk of damaging fork by overtightening or not getting the protection layer right
In short, cheaper options can work, but they aren’t the most convenient and will take some work to get right. They can also be risky to your bike and your safety if you don’t know what you’re doing.
It’s worth noting here that the Axle Pack has a rated max load of 11 pounds per side. Coincidentally(?) this is the same as the rating of the highest-rated cage I’ve seen, the Blackburn Outpost, and probably exceeds the rated max of most other cages out there. So you can feel good about loading it up in ways you would never dream of with clamp-style mounts.